“Green Broom”
I don’t enjoy recording cover songs, but, if I ever had to, I would up-armor some old sweet song.
One Hundred English Folk Songs, edited by Cecil J. Sharp, originally published in 1916, adds another dimension to my collection of song books. The song book is a collection of earlier songbooks: Reverand Broadwood’s folk songs from Sussex, published in 1843, among them.
It’s fun to look up the song titles on You Tube to see how many versions are posted. The song “Green Broom” pulls up dozens of different versions of the folk song. The book of English folk songs from 1916 doesn’t mention “Green Broom” is actually of Irish origin.
After reading Bob Dylan’s Chronicles, I became more interested in songs and their transmission and dispersion. “Green Broom” was passed down through the centuries to all parts of the world. The sheet music helped it survive, but other factors contributed to its longevity. Credit for its long life has to be given the story the song tells: in the case of “Green Broom” one could point to the fact that any man is made more attractive by having employment. When young Jack sells brooms in the street, he is spotted by a lady in bloom. Whether the lady is an old cougar isn’t mentioned yet somewhat implied.
Parents of teen boys can surely relate to “Green Broom” as it questions whether a boy who lies in his bed until noon will ever be able to catch a lady in bloom. Today, lads of the millennium generation suffer no short supply of ladies in bloom. If they have any job at all they get hit-on by ladies from 16 to 76…and not necessarily for marriage. Swarms of ladies peer from upstairs windows in need of a sleepy young lad crying ‘broom’ in the streets.
Broom itself is a toxic herb – counter-indicated for pregnancy. It’s the type of herb which can withstand a fire, growing back after its exposed half is scorched. As an invasive plant with many species thriving and spreading in the United States, other than rubbing it on the swelling of mosquito bites or taming wild horses, its flowers could still decorate country style weddings (if any such ceremonies remain of the old time Sussex variety).
I’m not sure if Fairport Convention ever recorded a version of “Green Broom”? It would interest me to listen to an electric version of the song played by them in their 60’s hippie style. The true beauty of a great song shows up when you hear it successfully played in different styles or varied combinations of instruments.
Bob Dylan wrote in Chronicles about when he showed up to play with The Grateful Dead in preparation for their tour, and they went down too long of a list of his songs. He had just come off a tour with Tom Petty and was most familiar with songs from those shows. How can someone who’s written so many songs be expected to play any particular one of them by request? Perhaps the best practice would have been for them to play “Green Broom” together, with Jerry Garcia playing an electric dulcimer with a glass bottle slide. Classic folk songs offer that common language, one to which players can bring their own unique talents.